⚠️ SHIPPING ALERT: Due to extreme heat in several regions, shipments of perishable items may be delayed. Learn more.
An assortment of cheeses, crackers, dried orange slices, nuts, salami, rosemary sprigs, and a bowl of fig jam arranged on a wooden board and white surface.

Non-Cheddars

Non-Cheddars

Filter & Sort
20 products
FeaturedMost relevantBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filter (0)
Cheese Type
Flavor
Sort by

Best Seller

Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese, 8 oz (226g), comes in orange and yellow packaging. This farmer-owned cheese is supremely smooth, protein-packed, and contains 0g lactose.

Gouda Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese, 8 oz (226g), comes in a green and red plaid package labeled “Farmer Owned” and “0g lactose per serving,” highlighting its spicy flavor perfect for nachos or snacking.

Pepper Jack Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamery Monterey Jack Cheese, in green and beige packaging, is a farmer-owned, premium natural melting cheese that's lactose free and weighs 8 oz (226g).

Monterey Jack Cheese
Cabot Creamery Colby Jack Cheese, 8 oz (226g) block with yellow and blue farm-themed packaging—ideal for shredding and melting in your favorite recipes.

Colby Jack Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese is a lactose free 8 oz (226g) spicy cheese with mild and medium peppers, featuring green accents and a red pepper illustration on the label.

Pepper Jack Cheese

Award Winner

A 7 oz package of Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese cracker cut slices, with creamy spicy cheese slices visible through a clear plastic container and topped with a green and red label.

Pepper Jack Cheese
Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese comes in a clear container with 26 slices—an ideal protein snack for any occasion.

Gouda Cheese
Cabot Creamery Colby Jack Cheese offers superior meltability and comes in a clear plastic package with a blue and cream label displaying the brand and product name, featuring 26 convenient cracker cuts.

Colby Jack Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese features zesty snack sticks made with spicy cheese. The red and green plaid 10-pack of 0.75 oz sticks is high in protein, farmer-owned, and lactose free.

Pepper Jack Cheese
A 10-count pack of Cabot Creamery Colby Jack Cheese features individually wrapped, creamy snack sticks in a blue and yellow plaid package with a clear window—ideal for everyday snacking.

Colby Jack Cheese

Award Winner

An 8 oz package of Cabot Creamery Monterey Jack Cheese features a green and cream plaid design and highlights its farmer-owned origins, mild flavor, and lactose free status.

Monterey Jack Cheese
An 8 oz lavender and cream-colored bag of Cabot Creamery Mozzarella Cheese features product details and a clear bottom window showing the shredded cheese inside.

Mozzarella Cheese
An 8-ounce bag of Cabot Creamery Mozzarella Part-Skim Cheese features classic cut shreds in a white and purple package. The product is labeled gluten free and contains 2 cups of cheese.

Mozzarella Part-Skim Cheese
Cabot Creamery Mozzarella Whole Milk Cheese comes in an 8 oz (226g) cream and purple bag with a window showing the cheese inside—ideal for pizza.

Mozzarella Whole Milk Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese, gluten-free and supremely creamy, comes in a red-and-beige plaid package with 9 convenient pre-sliced pieces—ideal for anyone who loves spicy cheese.

Pepper Jack Cheese
Cabot Creamery Swiss Cheese comes in a 7 oz package with a purple and cream plaid design, features 9 visible sandwich slices, and is labeled farmer-owned and gluten-free.

Swiss Cheese
Cabot Creamery Swiss Cheese, 10 slices (8 oz/226g), smooth finish, gluten-free, in beige and purple packaging with the Cabot logo.

Swiss Cheese
A package of Cabot Creamery White American Cheese—ideal for burgers and sandwiches. The blue and red box has 16 individually wrapped, gluten-free slices. Net weight: 12 oz (340g).

White American Cheese
A package of Cabot Creamery Yellow American Cheese, with 16 pre-wrapped slices (12 oz/340g), labeled pasteurized process cheese food, gluten-free, and ideal for sandwiches.

Yellow American Cheese
A resealable 8 oz (226g) bag of Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese, Classic Cut, features orange and yellow packaging with the brand logo, cheese type, "2 cups," and notes that it is lactose free.

Gouda Cheese

Shop Cabot Apparel

Wear your Cabot pride on your sleeve! Find an array of t-shirts, hats, hoodies and more.

shop apparel
Cabot Cutting Board with cheese cut up on it on a green background

Cheesy Accessories

Cheese the Day with accessories perfect for the cheese lover in your life!

Shop Accessories