Non-Cheddars

Non-Cheddars

Non-Cheddars

Filter & Sort
19 products
FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filter (0)
Cheese Type
Flavor
Out of stock
Sort by
Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese, 8 oz (227g), comes in orange packaging with white accents featuring Creamy, Dreamy, and Sweetly Nutty, Supremely Smooth, and 0g Lactose per Serving, crafted by Cabot farmers for a protein-packed snack.

Gouda Cheese
Cabot Creamerys Pepper Jack Cheese is a lactose-free, 8 oz (226g) premium natural cheese with a smooth, fiery spicy taste perfect for nachos and marked as hot.

Pepper Jack Cheese

Award Winner

An 8 oz (226g) package of Cabot Creamery Monterey Jack Cheese features a green and beige label declaring it farmer owned, natural, and 0g lactose. Ideal for Southwestern dishes, it offers a mellow, nutty flavor perfect for your favorite lactose-free recipes.

Monterey Jack Cheese
Cabot Creamerys Colby Jack Cheese comes in blue and white packaging with images of cheese slices, marked as Farmer Owned, Lactose Free, and Naturally Aged. Its perfect for melting and weighs 8 oz (226g).

Colby Jack Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamerys Pepper Jack Cheese, a lactose-free block with a green and white label, is Monterey Jack infused with mild and medium jalapenos. It is natural cheese weighing 8 oz (227g).

Pepper Jack Cheese
A package of Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese slices is shown in green and white packaging. It features 26 neatly stacked, creamy slices infused with jalapeno hints, and the label states Net WT 7 oz (200g).

Pepper Jack Cheese
A transparent plastic pack of Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese features an orange label with white text displaying the brand name and product. Inside are 26 protein-rich cracker cut slices, a delicious choice for nutritious snacking, ideal for any cheese lover.

Gouda Cheese
Cabot Creamery Colby Jack Cheese: Transparent packaging highlights yellow and white marbled slices. Label states 26 cracker cut slices, 7 oz (198g).

Colby Jack Cheese
Cabot Creamerys Pepper Jack Cheese Snack Sticks come in red, cream, and green plaid packaging with a pepper graphic. The package reads Pepper Jack Cheese Snack Sticks with Jalapenos and contains 10 sticks weighing a total of 7.5 oz.

Pepper Jack Cheese
Enjoy Colby Jack Cheese Snack Sticks from Cabot Creamery, ideal for daily snacking. The blue plaid bag includes ten 0.75 oz sticks, featuring a creamy blend with 5g Protein Per Stick and 0g Lactose, highlighted by a Farmer Owned seal.

Colby Jack Cheese
Savor Cabot Creamerys Monterey Jack Cheese, 8 oz of lactose-free, naturally mild shredded goodness in green packaging, offering a hint of southwestern tang with 0g lactose.

Monterey Jack Cheese
A purple and cream package of Cabot Creamery Mozzarella Cheese, labeled Low-Moisture Part-Skim Shredded Cheese, contains 8 oz (226g), is gluten-free, and ideal for Italian dishes.

Mozzarella Cheese
A package of Cabot Creamery Mozzarella Part-Skim Cheese in purple and cream packaging is labeled Low-Moisture Part-Skim Shredded Cheese, Classic Cut. It weighs 8 oz (226g) and is farmer-owned, gluten-free, and non-GMO.

Mozzarella Part-Skim Cheese
A package of Cabot Creamerys Mozzarella Whole Milk Cheese features a purple and cream plaid design. Labeled Low-Moisture Whole Milk Shredded Cheese with Classic Cut, it weighs 8 oz (226g), is gluten-free, B Corp certified, and ideal for pizza.

Mozzarella Whole Milk Cheese

Award Winner

Cabot Creamerys Pepper Jack Cheese, with 9 slices totaling 7 oz, features a red plaid package and is infused with jalapenos for a creamy spice. Its gluten-free and comes in a resealable pack.

Pepper Jack Cheese
Cabot Creamery Swiss Cheese is a farmer-owned, gluten-free, semi-soft cheese perfect for sandwiches. It comes in a package with a checkered cream and purple design, containing 9 slices totaling 7 oz.

Swiss Cheese
Cabot Creamery Swiss Cheese comes in an 8 oz (226g) package with 10 pre-sliced slices. The purple and white packaging features Gluten-Free and Smooth Finish labels, showcasing the semi-soft texture of this delightful cheese.

Swiss Cheese
A pack of Cabot Creamery White American Cheese slices features a red, white, and blue design with Farmer Owned, Perfect for Sandwiches, 16 Individually Wrapped Slices, and Gluten-Free. Weighing 12 oz (340g), this Pasteurized Process Cheese Food is perfect for cheeseburgers.

White American Cheese
Cabot Creamerys Yellow American Cheese package features 16 pre-wrapped, gluten-free slices, weighs 12 oz (340g), and is labeled pasteurized process cheese food—ideal for sandwiches.

Yellow American Cheese
Cabot Pie Law Shirt

Shop Cabot Merch

Choose from an assortment of tees, hoodies, onesies for the little one, tote bags and much more!

shop merch
Cabot Cutting Board with cheese cut up on it on a green background

Cheesy Accessories

Cheese the Day with accessories perfect for the cheese lover in your life!

Shop Accessories